When I was an undergraduate, and a barely reconstructed communist, I used to have warm feelings to the travel company “SovScot Tours“. This company promoted cultural exchange between the Soviet Union and Scotland and, while I never went on a single of their trips, I did enjoy some of the cultural exchanges they provided. A flatmate, and student of Slavonic languages, had seasonal work with them as a translator and this afforded him the chance to travel between the USSR and Scotland and consequently duty free goods.
The strongest recollections I have were of the vodka and cigarettes. The vodka was resinous and oily, slightly yellow and with a fierce alcohol rating. The vodka he brought back never lasted too long and I fear it may have left a permanent mark on my liver. The cigarettes lasted a little longer; they were Belomorkanal cigarettes which were hailed as the “strongest” cigarettes in the world. They had thick dark, tarry tobacco packed in he end of a cardboard tube. The bottom half of the tube was empty and acted as a cigarette holder and avoided the impediment of a filter – that burnt tobacco had unfettered access to your lungs. They lasted a little longer as they were so unpleasant, to regular Silk Cut and Sperkings users, for the same reason that the exotic holiday liqueur, with the rancid bitter taste, always is last to be emptied at parties. I have heard it said that the carboard tubes these cigarettes left behind made excellent “roaches” but as students in 70’s Glasgow we did not know about such things.
The other aspects of cultural exchange were lost on me and my flatmates. We were all Trotskyists and members of the Fourth International and could bore anyone, who was willing to listen, witless with our incisive and pedantic critique of why the Soviet Union was not “truely” communist. This was always very useful as it meant we could keep out faith in Communism without hindrance of any awkward facts.
I found myself thinking of those days recently, triggered by news from Russia and Scotland. It seems again, that the two countries have much in common; more than just a love of heavy drinking and Robert Burns.
The news in Russia about Alexei Navalny is frightening. It is clear that the state now sees the judicial system as its personal aide. When Putin feels threatened he has no compunction, nor difficulty, in using the legal system to get rid of his political enemies. When attempts to poison him with Novochoc failed the law came to the state’s aid. He was arrested and jailed for breaking parole – because he was on life support in a German Hospital at the time. In an attempt to destroy his reputation he has now been charged with being insulting and disrespectful of World War II veterans.
Why did this remind me of Scotland? Because a similar, sorry and distasteful take is occurring back home. Though a lot of the public spat between Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon seems to be about who said what and when; there is a lot more to this. We will probably never know the actual truth on when Nicola was told of the concerns about Salmond and we will never know how much was concocted in the concerns about him (He was not found guilty following a court hearing). The exact amount of lies that have been told will always remain open to interpetation. But the evidence that the governing party in Scotland has used its power to influence the organs of state, and in particular the legal system, to damage the reputation and influence of a political opponent is clear and growing. It is likely, like Navalny, they would have been quite happy to see Salmond jailed if possible so as to get him out of the scene.
Alex Salmond’s reputation has indeed been damaged. Nicola manages to hold on, buoyed by the public hatred of Boris Johnson and the media’s sympathy to her anti-Brexit stance, but it is starting to tarnish. The absence of any effective opposition party in Scotland leaves the Nation watching powerless as this calamity plays out. As I grew my politics changed and I was, for many years, an active member of the SNP. I have always argued for smaller political groupings as they are more responsive and more able to deliver democracy. However, at a time when independence seems closest for Scotland it also seems it may not be the best option – not under these leaders – the people of Scotland may vote to live in an independent Nation, they will not have been voting to live in anybody’s personal fiefdom. Were I living in Scotland I don’t honestly think I could vote for the SNP at this time, and those of my family who still live there will have an extremely difficult decision to make in the May elections